Skip to content

Operating ACME Clients

Section Overview: Practical guides for deploying, configuring, and operating ACME clients in production environments. This section bridges the gap between understanding the ACME protocol and successfully running automated certificate management at scale.

Why This Section Exists

The ACME Protocol documentation explains what ACME is and how it works at a protocol level. This section focuses on operating ACME clients in real-world production environments where you face practical challenges:

  • Configuring trust stores for private ACME servers
  • Managing ACME clients across development, staging, and production
  • Handling certificate validation in containerized environments
  • Debugging DNS-01 challenges across multiple cloud providers
  • Operating cert-manager in multi-tenant Kubernetes clusters
  • Configuring Certbot with organizational security policies

The Operational Gap

Most ACME documentation shows simple examples: 

certbot certonly --standalone -d example.com

Production reality involves: 

certbot certonly \
  --server https://acme.internal.company.com/directory \
  --cert-path /etc/pki/ca-trust/internal-acme-ca.pem \
  --dns-route53 \
  --dns-route53-propagation-seconds 30 \
  --deploy-hook /usr/local/bin/deploy-to-load-balancers.sh \
  --preferred-challenges dns-01 \
  --key-type ecdsa \
  --elliptic-curve secp384r1 \
  -d *.example.com -d example.com \
  --config-dir /var/lib/certbot-production \
  --logs-dir /var/log/certbot \
  --work-dir /var/tmp/certbot

This section provides the operational knowledge to bridge that gap.

Section Contents

📦 Certbot Installation

Status: ✅ Available

Production-ready Certbot installation across Linux distributions: - Snap installation (recommended, auto-updates) - Distribution packages (Ubuntu, Debian, CentOS, RHEL) - Docker containerized deployments - Kubernetes CronJob patterns - Plugin management (nginx, apache, DNS providers)

Topics covered: - Version conflict resolution - Enterprise proxy configuration - Plugin dependencies and installation - Multi-distribution standardization with Ansible - Security hardening and compliance documentation

When to read: START HERE - Before using Certbot for the first time

🔐 X.509 Certificate Verification

Status: ✅ Available

Understanding certificate verification is foundational to operating ACME clients. This guide covers: - Trust store management for public and private ACME servers - Certificate chain validation for ACME-issued certificates - Cross-platform verification (Linux, Windows, containers, Kubernetes) - OCSP and CRL checking for ACME certificates - Debugging verification failures in production

When to read: After installation, before deploying to production

⚙️ Certbot Renewal Automation

Status: ✅ Available

Production-grade Certbot renewal patterns covering: - Automated renewal with systemd timers and cron - Deployment hooks for multi-service environments - Multi-server certificate distribution - Zero-downtime renewal strategies - High-availability architectures - Monitoring integration and failure recovery

Topics covered: - Single-server and multi-server deployments - Deployment hook implementation with validation - Rate limiting and renewal scheduling - Enterprise distribution mechanisms - Rollback procedures and health checks

When to read: Before implementing production Certbot automation

⚙️ ACME Client Configuration Patterns

Status: 🚧 Coming Soon

Additional ACME client guides: - acme.sh: Lightweight shell-based ACME client - cert-manager: Kubernetes-native certificate management - Caddy: Web server with built-in ACME - Traefik: Reverse proxy with automatic HTTPS

🗃️ Trust Store Management

Status: 🚧 Coming Soon

Managing CA certificates across diverse environments: - System trust stores (Linux, Windows, macOS) - Container trust store management - Kubernetes ConfigMap-based trust distribution - Private ACME CA deployment and distribution - Trust store updates and CA certificate rotation

Use cases: - Private ACME servers in enterprise environments - Air-gapped environments without internet access - Multi-cloud deployments with different trust requirements - Development/staging environments with test CAs

✅ DNS-01 Challenge Validation

Status: ✅ Available

Complete implementation guide for DNS-01 challenges: - Wildcard certificate issuance (*.example.com) - Private network and firewall-restricted environments - DNS provider integrations (Cloudflare, Route53, Azure, Google Cloud DNS) - Automated DNS-01 with Certbot plugins and acme.sh - Enterprise multi-domain automation patterns - Kubernetes cert-manager DNS-01 configuration

Topics covered: - DNS propagation timing and troubleshooting - DNS API credential security and least-privilege access - Multi-cloud DNS provider strategies - Split-horizon DNS handling - Rate limiting and error recovery

When to read: When you need wildcard certificates or cannot use HTTP-01

✅ A Record Configuration

Status: ✅ Available

DNS A record fundamentals for ACME HTTP-01 validation: - A record structure and configuration patterns - Root domain and subdomain setup for ACME - CDN/proxy IP complications and solutions - Load balancer ACME challenge routing - Multi-server environments and certificate coordination

Topics covered: - Common A record misconfigurations breaking ACME validation - TTL optimization for certificate operations - Split DNS and internal/external DNS consistency - DNS provider-specific syntax and configuration - A record monitoring and change management

When to read: Before implementing HTTP-01 challenges, or when debugging "domain not reachable" ACME failures

✅ DNS A Record Implementation

Status: ✅ Available

Infrastructure-as-Code patterns for A record management at scale: - Terraform multi-provider A record automation - Ansible playbooks for DNS configuration - Python DNS management for programmatic control - Geographic distribution patterns for multi-region ACME - Public Suffix List considerations for dynamic DNS

Topics covered: - Multi-cloud DNS automation (AWS, Azure, GCP, Cloudflare) - TTL strategies for migrations and different environments - A record consistency validation and monitoring - Infrastructure-as-Code best practices - Split-brain DNS prevention and detection

When to read: When implementing ACME at scale across multiple regions or cloud providers

✅ ACME Challenge Validation (Additional Methods)

Status: 🚧 Coming Soon

Additional ACME challenge methods: - HTTP-01: Web server challenges and firewall considerations - TLS-ALPN-01: Port 443-only challenge validation

Operational scenarios: - Load balancer environments with HTTP-01 - TLS-ALPN-01 for port 443-only access

🌍 Multi-Environment ACME Operations

Status: 🚧 Coming Soon

Running ACME across development, staging, and production: - Environment-specific ACME server configuration - Let's Encrypt staging vs production - Private ACME servers for internal testing - Certificate lifecycle management per environment - Promoting certificates from staging to production

Patterns covered: - GitOps-based ACME configuration management - Environment variable-based ACME client configuration - Terraform/CloudFormation ACME resource management - CI/CD integration for certificate automation

🔧 Troubleshooting ACME Operations

Status: 🚧 Coming Soon

Debugging common ACME operational issues: - Rate limit handling and recovery - Challenge validation failures (DNS propagation, firewall issues) - Account key recovery and migration - Certificate chain problems - ACME server connectivity issues - Clock skew and time synchronization problems

📊 ACME Client Monitoring

Status: 🚧 Coming Soon

Observability for ACME automation: - Prometheus metrics for ACME operations - Alerting on renewal failures - Certificate expiration monitoring - ACME challenge validation metrics - Rate limit consumption tracking

Who Should Read This Section

Platform Engineers

Building automated certificate infrastructure: - Deploying cert-manager in Kubernetes - Integrating ACME with service mesh (Istio, Linkerd) - Automating certificate distribution to load balancers - Managing ACME at scale (1000+ certificates)

Security Engineers

Ensuring secure ACME operations: - Validating ACME server certificates - Managing trust stores and CA certificates - Implementing certificate pinning - Monitoring for unauthorized certificate issuance - Compliance requirements (SOC 2, ISO 27001)

DevOps Engineers

Operating ACME in production: - Configuring Certbot, acme.sh, or other clients - Debugging challenge validation failures - Implementing renewal automation - Managing certificates across cloud providers - CI/CD integration for certificate workflows

Site Reliability Engineers

Maintaining ACME reliability: - Monitoring certificate expiration and renewal - Implementing alerting for ACME failures - Handling ACME outages and degradation - Capacity planning for certificate volumes - Disaster recovery for ACME infrastructure

Learning Path

New to ACME? 1. Read ACME Protocol to understand the protocol 2. Start with Certbot Installation to get Certbot installed 3. Configure DNS: A Record Configuration 4. Set up automation: Certbot Renewal Automation 5. For wildcard certificates: DNS-01 Challenge Validation

Experienced with ACME? - Jump to specific operational topics you're troubleshooting - Review Troubleshooting ACME Operations for common issues - Implement ACME Client Monitoring for production observability

Running ACME at Scale? - Focus on Multi-Environment ACME Operations and Trust Store Management - Implement comprehensive ACME Client Monitoring - Review ACME Challenge Validation for advanced scenarios

Protocol & Standards: - ACME Protocol - Protocol specification and RFC 8555 - X.509 Standard - Certificate format details - TLS Protocol - TLS handshake and certificates

Operations: - Certificate Lifecycle Management - Broader lifecycle context - Renewal Automation - Automation strategies beyond ACME - Monitoring and Alerting - Monitoring frameworks

Implementation: - ACME Protocol Implementation - Building ACME servers - Multi-Cloud PKI - ACME in multi-cloud environments

Feedback and Contributions

This section is actively being developed. Topics marked "🚧 Coming Soon" are planned based on real-world operational challenges from Fortune 500 ACME deployments.

Priority roadmap: 1. ✅ Certbot Installation (Complete) - Foundation 2. ✅ A Record Configuration (Complete) - Prerequisites 3. ✅ DNS A Record Implementation (Complete) - Infrastructure 4. ✅ X.509 Certificate Verification (Complete) - Validation 5. ✅ Certbot Renewal Automation (Complete) - Operations 6. ✅ DNS-01 Challenge Validation (Complete) - Advanced challenges 7. 🚧 Trust Store Management (In Progress) 8. 🚧 HTTP-01 & TLS-ALPN-01 Challenges (Next) 9. 🚧 Multi-Environment ACME Operations (Planned) 10. 🚧 Additional ACME Clients (acme.sh, cert-manager) (Planned)

For questions about ACME operations or to suggest topics: Contact Axelspire

Last Updated: January 24, 2025
Maintained by: Axelspire - Enterprise PKI Consulting